What People Are Asking

Tradition In Action

True & False Right


True and False Right 


General Criteria

catholic What Is Your Take on the True & False Right?
What a false right is and the example of Bishop Schneider


catholicWhy Are TIA's Authors Boycotted by Other Traditionalists?
Distinction between false-right, 5th column & common thieves



SSPX

catholicWhat Does TIA Think about the SSPX-Rome Negotiations?
We believe the Bishops are preparing the faithful to accept a merge


catholicWhy Do SSPX' Priests Always Impose the 'Just Pray & Obey'?
To bring  as many people as they can to the merge - see previous answer


catholicWhy Did Card. Royos Say Bishop Fellay Accepted Vatican II?
Probably because Fellay did; check the consequences of a merge here


catholic Did You Read What Bishop Fellay Wrote about Your Criticism?
You can find our answer to it here


catholicDo You Believe SSPX Will Actually Compromise?
In theory, Fellay can step back; in practice, it seems the deal is made


catholicAren't You Losing Friends Because of Your Criticism of Fellay?
Our real friends are those who want to follow the truth without compromise


catholicWhy Did You Offend the Ladies Who Forwarded Fellay's Letter?
It seems your sensibilities are more delicate than the ladies'


catholicDid You Read the Documents Confirming Your Warning about Fellay?
Thank you for sending them – we are publishing them here for our readers


catholicHave You Seen the Compromise on the SSPX Website?
No, we have not. Thank you for your opportune comments


catholic Why Is an SSPX Priest Accusing TIA of Sede-Vacantism?
This priest is wrong. It is obvious that we are not sede-vacantists


catholicIs TIA Part of the St. Pius X Movement?  Another Similar Question
No, we are not


catholicIf You Are Not SSPX, What Branch of Traditionalism Do You Support?
TIA does not support branches, but Catholic principles


catholicWhat Are the Alternatives to SSPX in view of Its Compromise?
You can assist at Eastern Rite Masses that still maintain their old liturgies


catholicAre the Sacraments Administered by Bishop Galarreta Valid?
Yes, they are. Do not worry about that


catholicAre SSPX Confessions & Masses Valid even without Jurisdiction?
We believe they are; Faith has precedence over jurisdiction


catholicHow Can SSPX Administer the Sacraments without Jurisdiction?
To assist the preeminent needs of the lay people


catholicWhy Didn't Priests Leaving SSPX Present Evidence against Fellay?
They did, but TIA did not translate all the documents


catholicShould I Go to SSPX, FSSP or SPV Masses?
Here are the pros & cons; it is up to you to decide


catholicWhat about the Priory of Sion & Its Links with Lefebvre?
Here are the allegations, which oscillate between speculation & probability


catholicDoes the Schism of SSPX Make Its Previous Sacraments Invalid?
No, it does not


catholicGiven the SSPX Compromise, Should I Go to Another Mass? Where?
Even compromised, its Sacraments are valid; other possibilities are here


catholicCould You Clarify Why Fr. Meramo Was Expelled?
Find a summary of what happened here


catholicIs SSPX Making Concessions to Buddhism?
A close-up of a chapel in Tokyo showing ‘inculturation’


catholicThe Tokyo 'Space' Is Not a Chapel; Can't You See That?
Angelus magazine calls it a chapel, here are the original sources


catholicCan't You See It Is Just a Rented Place without Chairs?
SSPX has been there for 8 years & there are signs of inculturation


catholicDo You Know that SSPX Is Supporting Dorothy Day?
No, we did not. Thank you for the information


catholic Did You See The Angelus & Fr. Scott Attacked You for Attacking Gill?
Yes, we did; here is our refutation



FSSP, IGS & FSJV

catholicWas Fr. Bisig the True Successor of Arch. Lefebvre?
If he says this, it is better to ask him to prove it, not us


catholicHow Can You Prove the Fraternity of St. Peter Is Compromised?
It has the Bishops' approval, which only happens with the acceptance of Vatican II


catholicWhat Is Your Opinion on the Institute of Good Shepherd?
Read here how it has been strangled by the Vatican


catholicWhat Is Your Take on Bishop Rifan's Adhesion to the Novus Ordo Mass?
See his position and his apologia for the New Mass here


catholicCan We Say that Bishop Rifan Is a Traitor?
Yes we can, the proof is here


catholic Why Do You Say Fr. Rifan Was In the SSPX Cupola When He Was Not?
One of the highest authorities of the SSPX confirmed that he was


catholicCan We Say Rifan Is a Forerunner of Fellay?
Read Fellay's criticism of Rifan & see whether the former is on the same path



Distributism

catholicWhy Do So Many Traditionalists Support Distributism?
It is a way to divert attention from the fight against Progressivism


catholicIs Distributism Being Spread among Traditionalists to Destroy Them?
Yes, you are right; it is the scatter and divide tactic


catholicIs Distributism Catholic?
No, it is based not on the Popes but on Marx


catholicCan We Say Distributism Is a Masked Socialism?
Yes, we can; it explains Distributism perfectly


catholic What Is Your Take on Eric Gill, Founder of Distributism?
He was a morally corrupt man & a precursor of Vatican II


catholic Gill's Vices Don't Affect Distributism. Aren't Diamonds in the Mud?
The right metaphor is: The bad tree gives bad fruits; not that of diamonds


catholicIs Gill Bad or Good? Pros & Cons in a SSPX Forum
Defenses, objections, replies & critiques regarding Eric Gill


catholicWho Gave You the Right to Reproduce the Comments of Our Forum?
They were in the public domain; they were about our articles; we reproduced them


catholicDid You Not Sin Against Charity in Exposing Gill & His Vices?
No, we did not; we exposed a criminal for the sake of the public good


catholicWhy Do You Attack Gill's Art? His Art Is Not Connected to His Vices
We only attack his art insofar as his vices are present in it


catholicWeren't the Founders of Distributism Chesterton & Belloc and not Gill?
These socialists leaders were all founders, but Gill was the principal one


catholicWhat Do You Think about Hilaire Belloc?
He was a liberal disguised in traditionalist robes


catholicWere Chesterton & Tolkien also Bad?
We plan to study Chesterton - Tolkien was not linked to Distributism


catholicWhy Are You Condemning Belloc & Chesterton by Association?
Odou is not doing this; he is studying each one individually


catholicWas Arthur Penty as Good as Many People Say?
His teachings are analyzed here, here & here


catholicWhat About the Other Great Thinkers of Distributism?
They hold the same position as the ones we quoted


catholicCan I Translate Your Articles to Fight Distributism?
Yes, you can; here are the conditions



Nazism, Fascism etc.

catholicIs Nazism a Movement of the Left or the Right?
It is a false right to direct anti-communists to Socialism


catholic What Is Your Position on Nazism?
It is a Gnostic-Manichean sect; read this series


catholicDid You See the Southern Poverty Law Center Attacked You?
Yes, we did; here is our refutation


catholic Indignation over the SPLC Attack against TIA
Readers react strongly in our favor


catholicCan You Cite a Good Catholic Reaction to Nazism?
Yes, we can; here is an overview of a reaction by Baroness von Guttenberg


catholic Have the Nazis Practiced Euthanasia?
Yes, they have; read Card. von Gallen's heroic reaction against it here & here


catholicWas the Priory of Sion a Nazi Order?
We don't know; you can come to your own conclusions reading this report


catholicIs It True that Belloc Admired Mussolini?
Yes, he was an adept of Mussolini & Fascism


catholicDoes Modern Art Have Any Link with Nazism?
Yes, it does; read here what is behind Futurism & Surrealism


catholic Are There Other Movements Similar to Nazism?
Yes, Fascism, Petainism, Francoism, Salazarism, Integralism are some of them



Card. Ottaviani, Siri, Newman & Arch. Sheen

catholicDid Cardinal Ottaviani Accept Progressivism?
Yes, he did; check this document here


catholicI Have Heard Ottaviani Supported the U.N. Is It True?
Yes, he did; read his declaration


catholic Can't You See that Ottaviani Didn't Accept Progressivism? You Are Wrong
Your document does not address the point you imagine


catholic Wasn't Card. Siri Elected Pope & Forced into Seclusion?
He publicly denied any support for those who consider him pope


catholic Did Card. Siri Accept the Conciliar Popes?
Yes, he did, check these links here, here & here


catholic Can You Present Proof Siri Said the New Mass?
Yes, here you have some photos of him saying the Novus Ordo Mass


catholic Do You Have Solid Evidence Proving Newman Was a Liberal?
Yes, we do, read this series of documents taken from his works


catholicWhy Do You Say Newman Was a Liberal?
Because he in fact was one, as proved here


catholicIs It Certain that Newman Opposed Pius IX?
Yes, it is, read here, here & here


catholicWhat Do You Think about Newman's Beatification?
We believe he was not a saint; read here, here & here


catholicDo You Have Any Article by Brownson against Newman?
Yes, he wrote a book against Newman; here is a review of it


catholic Did Fr. Feeney Ever Attack Newman?
Yes, we published one of his attacks here


catholicWere the Newman Centers Named After Newman or Neumann?
After Card. John Henry Newman, the Liberal


catholic Is It True Newman Never Completely Converted?
Yes, he continued to defend Anglicanism all his life


catholicWas Newman a Homosexual?
It is not certain, but there are many symptoms he was; read here, here & here


catholicIs It Sure that Newman's Body Was Completely Pulverized?
Yes, when his grave was opened, neither bones nor teeth were left


catholicFulton Sheen is Often Pictured with Protestants. Was He Ecumenical?
Yes, he was an early promoter of interfaith meetings and talks


catholicWas Arch. Sheen a Socialist of Some Sort?
He defended a notion of co-ownership very similar to that of Socialism


catholicWas Fulton Sheen Favorable to the New Mass & Vatican II?
Yes, he was an enthusiast of the Council and said the New Mass


catholic Is It True That Fulton Sheen Admired Teilhard de Chardin?
Yes, in his biography he spends a chapter defending Chardin


catholic What About Sheen's Cause of Beatification?
It was suspended; read here





Questions  |  Comments  |  Objections  |  Home  |  Books  |  CDs  |  Search  |  Contact Us  |  Donate

Tradition in Action
© 2002-    Tradition in Action, Inc.    All Rights Reserved