Objections to TIA and their answers @ TraditionInAction.org

What People Are Saying

	Fellay: The SSPX Bishops Did Not Compromise; Your Critique Is a Delirium Guimarăes responds and asks: Did you accept the legitimacy of Vatican II or not?
	Fr. Fernando Rifan Was Never a Decision-Maker in the SSPX Cupola Guimarăes expounds on the basis of his previous statement
	Your Position of Resistance Is Wrong; Sede-Vacantism Is Right TIA rebuts the simplistic reasoning of a sede-vacantist reader
	*Quo Primum vs. Novus Ordo* TIA summarizes its position regarding the illegitimacy of the New Mass
	Your Comments on Pictures Are Foolish - Here is the Evidence A reader reveals his liberalism by ignoring immoralities and improprieties
	Say Heretic and Not Progressivist; You Are Using Propaganda Photos Two readers send objections to our language and photos. Two answers.
	You Sinned against Charity and Purity by Exposing Gill Fr. Peter Scott indirectly attacks Patrick Odou's articles. Read the rebuttal.
	On the Attack of the Southern Poverty Law Center TIA accused of being 'dirty' and 'anti-semitic' - Guimarăes responds.
	There Is No Evidence that St. Paul Avoided Crucifixion From Oxford a reader criticizes Prof. Plinio's "strident" remarks. The editor responds.
	You Should Have Compassion for Ducks and Other Livestock A covert eco-terroist explodes over our position on animals. Read TIA's reply.
	You Can't Say that Mother Teresa Was Praying to Gandhi No one can know what someone is thinking. One reader attacks us, another supports us.
	Blair Is Not Episcopalian and Judaism Is Not Bad. You Are Wrong. An English reader accuses TIA of imprecision in facts. Read our response.
	“The Rock” & Rock 'n' Roll: A Clarification and Some Objections Fr. Rick Stary: Dances are valid cultural expressions at Masses. TIA responds.
	A Dispute over the Rainbow Fr. Gabriel Burke: The vestments of Bishops at WYD 1997 had no homosexual connotations.
	There Are Exaggerations in Your Pictures of the Week The attitudes of JPII and Benedict XVI are not revolutionary. Our response.
	The New Mass Is Not Protestant. You Are Wrong. A convert objects. Fr. Stephen Somerville responds.
	You Gave No Evidence that Judaism Destroyed Christendom A reader demands the proof. Guimarăes offers it.
	The "Anathemas" of John Grasmeier A multi-argument attack by two journalists against TIA. Guimarăes refutes it.
	We Should Leave the Decision on the Two Sister Lucys to Forensic Experts Our answer: Although such opinions are important, they are not decisive.
	*The Inside the Vatican* Photo Is Mislabeled - You Are Conspiracy Maniacs** The Sr. Lucy controversy: A reader defends the magazine and attacks TIA. Our response.
	Wildfire Spreading over Sister Lucy's Photos Pros and cons on whether there are two Sister Lucys of Fatima.
	It's a Waste of Time to Study Our Colonial History It is better to be concerned with today's crisis in the Church. Dr. Horvat responds.
	Don't Link Eric Gill and His Sexual Deviations to Distributism A reader presents four different objections. TIA responds.
	Cardinals Rampolla and Gasparri Could Not Be Bad. You Are Wrong Pope Pius X kept them in the Curia, so how could they be Masons? Our response.
	Why Don't You Discuss the Main Authors of Distributism? We just did. Two days ago (November 28, 2005) an article was posted addressing this point.
	Should Our Lady of Good Success Carry a Crosier? Yes, she should. There is nothing unusual in this depiction of Our Lady.
	It Is Good to Have a Dancing Bishop Bishop Britt was just "praising the Lord." TIA responds.
	Diverting Attention from the Distributist Polemic? You cannot post my name in your repercussions - About Odou's articles on Eric Gill.
	The Subjective Morals of Mr. Karl Keating An attack on a review by Dr. Horvat on WYD and some captions of 2005 WYD photos on our site.
	Against TIA's Supposedly Utopic Standards of Culture From Zimbabwe: Nothing traditionalist can come from the U.S.
	*The Book Previews of the New Papacy* Contains Heresy** Fr. Robert Savage accuses: The divinity of Christ is denied. Follow the controversy.
	A Torrent of Pros and Cons on Eric Gill, A Founder of Distributism Anonymous Gill admirers attack Odou's critique of his pornographic art and perverted lifestyle.
	Nothing Is Wrong with Paul VI Wearing the Jewish High Priest Symbol Fr. Joseph Santos accuses that TIA's criticism of Paul VI is due to ignorance.
	There Is No Implication of the Pope in the Cover-Up Scandal From Kansas City: an objection to the article Papal Letter by Guimarăes.
	You Cannot Condemn Women Wearing Trousers Today From London: an objection to Horvat's article Good Ideas Fit With Good Customs.