Faith under Attack
A New Attack on Virginity
Contraceptive Pills for Nuns
Marian T. Horvat, Ph.D.
Faith under Attack | Religious | Home | Books | CDs | Search | Contact Us | Donate
The modern world has no limits when it comes to attacking the virtue of chastity and the state of virginity. The audacity and inanity of the latest assault, however, left me stunned.
Under the topic Women’s Health, Fox News reports with all seriousness the proposal that nuns should be offered the contraceptive pill on health grounds, because it would supposedly cut their risk of getting cancer. According to a study in online medical journal The Lancet, “The vow of chastity taken by the world's 95,000 Catholic nuns carries with it an increased risk of breast, ovarian and uterine cancers – all of which are more common in women who do not have children.”(1) They affirm that lack of pregnancy and lactation means childless women have more menstrual cycles, which increases cancer risk.
The study authors, Kara Britt of Monash University and Roger Short of the University of Melbourne, pretend that taking modern contraceptive pills could be the answer to the “problem.” It is one of those problems, obviously, that no one knows about until he is duly informed by academic committees and the media.
An inane call for the birth control pill for chaste nuns
They base their conclusion on statistics that show overall mortality in women using the contraceptive pill is around 12% lower than in those who have never used it and the risk of developing ovarian and endometrial cancers falls by 50% to 60%.
"If the Catholic Church could make the oral contraceptive pill freely available to all its nuns, it would reduce the risk of those accursed pests, cancer of the ovary and uterus, and give the nuns' plight the recognition it deserves," the doctors say. This “nun’s plight” is one, they blithely assert, that has been recognized “for hundreds of years ever since in 1713, Italian physician Bernadino Ramazzini reported nuns had extremely high rates of the ‘accursed pest,’ breast cancer.”
What these doctors fail to report is that this lone physician Ramazzini – whose study was resurrected by Planned Parenthood to fit its agenda – also reported the virtual absence of cervical cancer in nuns. He speculated that this protection was also related to their chaste lifestyle.
But this part of his findings is purposively left out, leading the public to surmise that nuns and religious women from the time of the Middle Ages were less healthy and suffering from diseases caused by their virginity. So, based on this tailored conclusion, now these doctors pretend that modern science will resolve the problem with the birth control pill.
Skewed data to make a false point
The birth control pill is presented as the magic solution to bring better health to the chaste nuns. In fact, there are many married and unchaste women taking the pill who have breast cancer and, according to other better-researched studies, they suffer a significantly higher risk of cervical cancer. These women also face a myriad of other side effects that make the so-called “cure” much worse than the potential risk of having the disease.
Indeed, as the body tries to adjust to increased estrogen and progesterone levels induced by the pill, women can experience a constant feeling of nausea, morning sickness, bloating and weight gain, acne, headaches, mood swings, hypertension and decreased resistance to infection. These are just some of the short term effects of the pill.
Anxiety is just one of the terrible side effects of the pill
Additionally, more serious and long term side effects are blood clots, depression, optical deficiency, gallstones, benign liver tumors, strokes or heart attacks, jaundice clotting, thrombosis and, as noted above, cervical cancer. (2)
So, it seems to me quite irrational that, to reduce a hypothetical risk of getting breast cancer, these nuns should take the birth control pill, which involves a proven higher risk of getting cervical cancer, along with the legion of other bad side effects mentioned.
Further, there are reliable data from previous research that actually associates contraceptive pill use with breast cancer in young women. (3) Those studies were also disregarded, since the results clash with the underlying thesis of these doctors, who insinuate virginity is a disease, an anomaly, an unnatural condition that must be treated...
Offering religious nuns the pill also seems to be an attempt to change the sexual morality of nuns as it did for the youth of the 1960s and 70s
Virginity and longevity
In a long term research project dubbed the Nun Study, Dr. David Snowdon studied 678 Catholic nuns from 75 to 107 years of age who took the vow of chastity at the average age of 22. What he found was that these religious women actually lived longer and healthier lives than lay women. In 1986 he published his discoveries in a book titled Aging with Grace: What the Nun Study Teaches Us about Leading Longer, Healthier, and More Meaningful Lives.
It was not the birth control pill that kept these nuns healthy mentally and physically, but their virginity that directed them to a calm, structured life and a simple and regular alimentary diet.
At left, three of the sisters observed in the Nun Study; at right, modern religious women at a social justice conference
I am not sure that a study about modern nuns living in apartments, immersed in the world, engaged in social justice, and having an ambivalent attitude about chastity would provide the same results. The religious women in the Nun Study had been trained in the pre-Vatican II Catholic Church, when the lifestyle of nuns was healthful both spiritually and physically.
This holds true all the way back to the Middle Ages. All the works I came upon during my study of medieval history confirmed that the index of longevity for nuns in medieval Europe was higher than for married women. One reason for this was related precisely to their vow of chastity: the religious women did not face the risk of dying in childbirth.
Not only did nuns in the Middle Ages live longer, but they led remarkably active lives into their old age, more so than the average women of the period, including the noblewomen. Just a few examples: Hildegarde of Bingen (1098-1179) founded a new convent near Rupertsberg at age 52 and another in Eibingen at age 67. Juliana of Falconieri (1270-1341) founded the female Order of Servites when she was 63 and headed it until her death at 70. The mystic Mechtilde of Magdeburg (1210-1297) entered the convent of Helfta in her early 60s and died there at age 87.
Abbess St. Hildegarde wrote a book of remedies for her nuns, breast cancer was not mentioned...
The longer life span and good health of the virgin nuns continued into the Renaissance and early Modern age. Studying the records of two Florentine convents from the late 15th to the late 18th centuries and comparing them to records of married women from the same social class, Stanford history Professor Judith Brown found that the nuns lived longer. “From a demographic point of view,” she wrote, “the nuns fared better than the best-nourished and the most-privileged women in Europe." (4)
Will the Vatican approve the nun’s pill?
At the end of the Fox News report on the pill for nuns, we read that even though the Catholic Church officially condemns all forms of contraception except abstinence, the use of the pill for nuns would be possible under regulations on birth control set out by Pope Paul VI in Humanae Vitae in 1968. This document stated that "the Church in no way regards as unlawful therapeutic means considered necessary to cure organic diseases, even though they also have a contraceptive effect." (5)
In the present day progressivist climate of the Church, one can only wonder whether this new attack on virginity will receive the approval of the Vatican.
1. "Birth Control Pills May Keep Nuns Healthy, Study Says," FoxNews online, December 8, 2011
2. "Birth Control Medications," E-Medicine health online; "Gynecologists Unfazed by Birth Control Clot Concerns," Bloomberg.com online, December 8, 2011
3. In one of the most comprehensive studies on the topic in 1996, the results showed that current and past pill users had a slightly increased risk of breast cancer. “Cancer and Birth Control Bills,” Women’s’ Health Specialists online
4. "Everyday Life, Longevity, and Nuns in Early Modern Florence," in Everyday Life in Early Modern Europe: Practice and Representation, Patricia Fumerton and Simon Hunt, eds. (University of Pennsylvania Press, 1998).
5. "Birth Control Pills May Keep Nuns Healthy," Fox News
Posted on December 10, 2007
Related Topics of Interest
What Is to Blame for the Demographic Catastrophe?
German & Austrian Bishops Rework their Acceptance of Birth Control
Virginity Is a Higher State than Matrimony
Prejudices against Chastity and Virginity
The Strength, Glory & Fecundity of Chastity
Nuns Dance at Conference
The Abortion Nun of Illinois
©2002-2011 Tradition in Action, Inc. All Rights Reserved